People often confuse the terms "preferred return" and "IRR hurdles" because both concepts are related to the distribution of profits in real estate and private equity investments, and they both aim to ensure investors achieve certain financial benchmarks. However, there are key differences between them that can help clarify their distinct roles:
Relevant Templates:
Preferred Return
- Definition: A preferred return, often referred to as a "pref," is a pre-agreed rate of return that limited partners (LPs) must receive on their investment before the general partners (GPs) can receive any carried interest or promote. It is usually expressed as an annual percentage.
- Purpose: It ensures that the LPs achieve a minimum return on their investment before profits are shared according to the partnership agreement.
- Calculation: It is typically calculated on the contributed capital and is cumulative, meaning if the preferred return is not met in one year, it accrues and must be paid in subsequent years before profit sharing with the GP occurs.
IRR Hurdles
- Definition: IRR (Internal Rate of Return) hurdles are specific return thresholds that must be achieved for different tiers of profit distribution to take effect. These hurdles are used to structure the promote or carried interest that the GP receives.
- Purpose: They are used to incentivize the GP to maximize returns. As each hurdle is surpassed, the GP receives a higher share of the profits.
- Calculation: IRR hurdles are calculated based on the overall performance of the investment over time, taking into account the timing and amount of cash flows.
Key Differences
Return Type:
- Preferred Return: Focuses on ensuring a minimum return on invested capital for LPs before profit sharing.
- IRR Hurdles: Establishes multiple return thresholds that determine the allocation of profits between LPs and GPs.
Application:
- Preferred Return: Applies to the LP's capital contributions and must be paid before any profits are distributed to the GP.
- IRR Hurdles: Apply to the total returns of the investment and determine the split of profits based on performance.
Incentive Structure:
- Preferred Return: Protects the LP's downside risk by ensuring they receive a baseline return.
- IRR Hurdles: Provides performance-based incentives for the GP, encouraging them to achieve higher returns.
Example Scenario
Imagine a real estate investment with a preferred return of 8% vs IRR hurdles at 12% and 18%:
- Preferred Return: The LPs must receive an 8% annual return on their invested capital before any profits are shared with the GP.
- IRR Hurdles: If the investment achieves an IRR of 12%, profits are split in a predetermined manner (e.g., 80% to LPs and 20% to GP). If the IRR exceeds 18%, the split might shift further in favor of the GP (e.g., 70% to LPs and 30% to GP).
Sources
Check out all the real estate and private equity waterfall models I've built.
Article found in joint venture.
